Finding the Sweet Spot for Metrics
Finding "Directionally Significant" Measurements
Metrics and measurements can feel reductive and fail to capture nuance. They often create unintended consequences when implemented poorly—driving behaviors that optimize for the metric rather than the true goal. Conversely, we sometimes overwork metrics because we crave certainty, hoping that more data will somehow reveal the "right" answer rather than simply informing our judgment.
To drive meaningful change and achieve success, you need:
Clear, Well-Calibrated Goals
Set at the appropriate level of ambition and specificity
Aligned with your current business reality and strategy
Realistic and informed by available data and context
Effective Goal Translation
Cascade goals meaningfully through the organization
Enable individuals to see their direct contribution at both strategic and tactical levels
Create line-of-sight from daily work to organizational objectives
Right-Sized Measurement Systems
Find balance between gut-feel decision-making and metric overload
Design metrics that inform rather than dictate decisions
Avoid metrics that drive counterproductive behaviors or create excessive administrative burden
A Better Approach to Measurement
When seeking to improve performance in any area, avoid these common mistakes:
The Intuition Trap: Relying solely on periodic gut checks creates inconsistency and recency bias in decision-making
The Bureaucracy Trap: Implementing complex tracking systems often creates work avoidance, gaming behaviors, and excessive administrative overhead
Instead, look for a balanced approach: Implementing lightweight measurement systems that:
Translate expert judgment into trackable data points that are easy to track
Provide directional insights without claiming false precision
Supplement rather than replace expert judgment
Reveal trends over time without micromanagement
In summary,
Start with clarity: Define what success truly looks like
Cascade thoughtfully: Help every level understand how they contribute
Measure minimally: Create the simplest metrics that provide useful direction
Use metrics as tools: Remember that metrics inform decisions, not make them
Review and refine: Regularly assess whether your metrics are driving the right behaviors
Good metrics should feel like a helpful compass, not a controlling taskmaster. They should illuminate your path without dictating every step of the journey.
…
Did you know we have a sibling publication? Practicing Serendipitist tells the stories and explores the practice of serendipity. Join us to see how you can bring more serendipity into your work and life »